Categories
Liberty Politics & government

[1780] Of is the defection by SAPP immoral?

Without doubt, there are individuals and groups which oppose Pakatan Rakyat’s idea of forming the federal government via defection. These groups rationalize their opposition by stating the voters elected the current government into power and not the current opposition. That rationale could be deconstructed further: voters’ main factor in voting a candidate into office is his political association and not the political belief or the characteristics of the candidate himself.

Given this, I wonder how the groups view SAPP’s defection from Barisan Nasional. Is it as immoral as Pakatan Rakyat’s idea?

I see no difference between SAPP’s action and Pakatan Rakyat’s proposal. Both violate the rationale of the individuals and groups which oppose formation of government via defection. I therefore expect the individuals and groups to oppose SAPP’s decision to quit Barisan Nasional and still retain the seats which SAPP won on March 8.

I personally do not buy the idea because the fact remains that in the system we live in, we vote individuals into office, not political parties. As a result, there is nothing undemocratic about forming a government via defection. Besides, willing defection is about freedom of association.

Categories
Liberty

[1778] Of Malaysia Day, 2008

Last year was a depressing year. This year, it is slightly better.

Wikipedia. Public domain.

Categories
Liberty Politics & government

[1775] Of Zaid Ibrahim quits!

One:

DATUK Zaid Ibrahim has tendered his resignation as the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department. He has just submitted his letter to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi. [Zaid Quits. New Straits Times. September 15 2008]

Two:

KUALA LUMPUR: Speculation is rife that de facto law minister Datuk Zaid Ibrahim has resigned.

According to sources, the senator tendered his letter of resignation to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi’s office just before 2pm on Monday. [Zaid Ibrahim Quits. The Star. Shaila Koshy. September 15 2008]

Three:

Datuk Zaid Ibrahim has resigned as Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department.

The Malaysian Insider has confirmed that he has tendered his resignation letter. [The Malaysian Insider. September 15 2008]

Four:

De facto Law Minister Zaid Ibrahim tenders his resignation over the government’s use of ISA, which allows detention without trial, against three individuals last week. [Law Minister Zaid ‘tenders resignation’. Fauwaz Abdul Aziz. Malaysiakini. September 15 2008]

There are so few politicians that stand by their words. Zaid Ibrahim has proven that he is one of them, yet again.

Categories
Activism Liberty Photography

[1774] Of candlelight vigil at Bukit Aman

There was a vigil at Bukit Aman just now, in response to the arrest of 3 individuals under the anti-liberty Internal Security Act.

And like any internet-savvy people, I got my invitation through Facebook. Heh!

Some rights reserved. By Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams.

I came alone and it was intimidating initially. I was not very confident about the whole idea. A friend described the idea of having the vigil at Bukit Aman’s beautifully: protesting at the lion’s den. I do not know how others would act in front of a lion but I would certainly nervous.

I did not relish the idea of going to the headquarters of the police and I did not want to come initially. However, I thought the vigil is important in a sense that it shows that the civil society is not easily intimidated. Where else to best demonstrate this other than at the lion’s den?

Besides, it would be another great opportunity to practice night photography.

Police officers everywhere and definitely in large number compared to the vigil participants.

Parking space was another issue because the police was manning the place religiously. And I did not want to park so closely to the gathering because if anything unfortunate to happen, I would not want anything to happen to the car, especially when it is not mine to start with. In the end, I decided to park so far away that I met my quota of physical exercise for the whole week tonight alone.

As I walked toward the planned gathering spot, I was stopped by an officer. He prevented me from walking toward the entrance of the police HQ. I was clearly unhappy but I did not force my way through. It would have been stupid to do so.

Since there are two ways to the entrance, I wanted to try my luck at the second entrance. The officer, probably realizing what I had in mind said loudly that the way was shut too. I waved him off, refusing to listen.

I got passed the barricade and joined the group for the event. We did not get to the entrance but this was close enough. There was strength in numbers and it did not feel so bad after that.

After that, it was a game of cat and mouse with the police. Each time the police told us to disperse, we just walked to another place to gather. The process was repeated a number of times and it definitely annoyed the officers.

Some rights reserved. By Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams.

The police made threats about arresting us and frankly, I did feel scare (but definitely not as bad as the one at Dataran Merdeka a couple of months back) but I realized in the end, neither sides were prepared to escalate the tension to, perhaps, the logical end in any country unconscious of individual liberty. It is somewhat similar to the classic case of why a strike is an irrational solution to a dispute.

So, all ended well and peacefully. For tonight.

Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved

p/s — More photos will be made available at Metblogs KL soon.

pp/s — I have posted more photos at Metblogs KL.

Categories
Liberty

[1773] Of friends, Malaysians, countrymen, lend me your ears

Friends, Malaysians, countrymen, lend me your ears
I come to bury Liberty, not to praise Liberty.
The evil that men do lives after them;
The good is oft interred with their bones;
So let it be with Liberty.  The noble Prime Minister
Hath told you Liberty was menacing
If it were so, it was a grievous fault,
And grievously hath Liberty answered it.
Here, under leave of the Prime Minister and the rest —
For the Prime Minister is an honorable man;
So are they all, all honorable men —
Come I to speak in Liberty’s funeral.
Liberty was my friend, faithful and just to me
But the Prime Minister says Liberty was a menace;
And the Prime Minister is an honorable man.
He hath brought many captives home,
Whose shackle did Liberty breaks
Did this in Liberty seem menacing?
When that the shackled had cried, Liberty hath wept.
Menace should be made of sterner stuff
Yet the Prime Minister says Liberty was menacing;
And the Prime Minister is an honorable man.
You all did see that before
When the Prime Minister was slumbering,
Liberty saved us: was this menacing?
Yet the Prime Minister says Liberty was menacing;
And, sure, the Prime Minister is an honorable man.
I speak not to disprove what the Prime Minister spoke,
But here I am to speak what I do know.
You all did love Liberty once, not without cause
What cause withholds you then to mourn for Liberty?
O judgment! Thou art fled to brutish beasts,
And men have lost their reason!  Bear with me;
My heart is in the coffin there with Liberty,
And I must pause till my heart comes back to me.

Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved Mohd Hafiz Noor Shams. Some rights reserved

p/s — surely, whose lines improvised, is clear for attribution. Else pick up those leaves, and turn them religiously.